Гомін - газета, телебачення, радіо
Radioprograma Song Of Ukraine
HominForumTV
Пожертва
Розсилка
No Result
View All Result
  • en EN
  • uk UA
  • Головна
  • Усі новини
    • Новини з України
    • Навколо світу
    • Політика
    • Акценти
    • Діаспора
    • Канадські події
    • Збройні Сили України
    • Економіка та бізнес
    • Молодь
    • Жіноцтво
    • Історія
    • Українці в Канаді
    • Література і мистецтво
    • Релігія і філософія
    • Наука і освіта
    • Спорт
    • Посмертні згадки
  • Світ
  • Україна
  • Канада
  • Політика
  • Публікації
  • Форум ТБ

    Forum TV: Levada & Orion 40 Years concert

    Forum TV: Vyshyvanka Commemorative Bench Unveiling

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Anna Kisil Commemoration Concret

    Forum TV: Ucrainica - Lubomyr Luciuk - "Holodomor" - Full version

    Forum TV: Interview with Refat Chubarov

    Forum TV: Interview with ViolaSet

    Forum TV: Remembrance Day - 2026

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us #5

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 09, November 07 2026

    Метелики спогадів Ірини Сеник

    Forum TV: 17-ті Вечорниці, організовані Ліґою Українок Канади відділ Торонто. “За двома зайцями”

    Forum TV: Law and Us #3

    Forum TV: Musical Fridays - Ludwig van Beethoven - Sonata N9

    Forum TV: Canadian Bandurist Capella Concert - "Bakhmut Fortress"

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us #4

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 08, October 31, 2026

    Forum TV: UCRAINICA, Alik Homelsky Lecture - full version

    Forum TV: Alik Homelsky Lecture

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview STAN KUTCHER Bill Passed

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview with Eva Rayska

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Anna Kisil Commemoration Concret

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 07, October 24, 2026

    Forum TV: Law and Us #2

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Interview with Taras Podilsky

    Forum TV: Ukrainian Fest - Cultural Segment

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 06, October 17, 2026

    Forum TV: UCWC Toronto Lesia Ukrainka Commemoration

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 05, October 10 2026

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us - «Закон і Ми»

    Forum TV: Interview with Анна Паленчук

    Forum TV: KUMF - Oleg Lipchenko exhibition, «Il Carosello Divino»

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 04, October 03 2026

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Ukrainian Fest - Community Segment

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    UCWLC 65th Anniversary

    Forum TV: Interview with Chris Alexander

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Interview with Victor Malarek

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview with Stan Kutcher

    Forum TV: Ucrainica - Lubomyr Luciuk-Holodomor

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 02, September 19 2026

    Forum TV: Brilliant Academy

    Forum TV: Ihor Dmytruk Exhibition

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 01, September 12 2026

  • Оголошення
  • Головна
  • Усі новини
    • Новини з України
    • Навколо світу
    • Політика
    • Акценти
    • Діаспора
    • Канадські події
    • Збройні Сили України
    • Економіка та бізнес
    • Молодь
    • Жіноцтво
    • Історія
    • Українці в Канаді
    • Література і мистецтво
    • Релігія і філософія
    • Наука і освіта
    • Спорт
    • Посмертні згадки
  • Світ
  • Україна
  • Канада
  • Політика
  • Публікації
  • Форум ТБ

    Forum TV: Levada & Orion 40 Years concert

    Forum TV: Vyshyvanka Commemorative Bench Unveiling

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Anna Kisil Commemoration Concret

    Forum TV: Ucrainica - Lubomyr Luciuk - "Holodomor" - Full version

    Forum TV: Interview with Refat Chubarov

    Forum TV: Interview with ViolaSet

    Forum TV: Remembrance Day - 2026

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us #5

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 09, November 07 2026

    Метелики спогадів Ірини Сеник

    Forum TV: 17-ті Вечорниці, організовані Ліґою Українок Канади відділ Торонто. “За двома зайцями”

    Forum TV: Law and Us #3

    Forum TV: Musical Fridays - Ludwig van Beethoven - Sonata N9

    Forum TV: Canadian Bandurist Capella Concert - "Bakhmut Fortress"

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us #4

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 08, October 31, 2026

    Forum TV: UCRAINICA, Alik Homelsky Lecture - full version

    Forum TV: Alik Homelsky Lecture

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview STAN KUTCHER Bill Passed

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview with Eva Rayska

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Anna Kisil Commemoration Concret

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 07, October 24, 2026

    Forum TV: Law and Us #2

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Interview with Taras Podilsky

    Forum TV: Ukrainian Fest - Cultural Segment

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 06, October 17, 2026

    Forum TV: UCWC Toronto Lesia Ukrainka Commemoration

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 05, October 10 2026

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us - «Закон і Ми»

    Forum TV: Interview with Анна Паленчук

    Forum TV: KUMF - Oleg Lipchenko exhibition, «Il Carosello Divino»

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 04, October 03 2026

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Ukrainian Fest - Community Segment

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    UCWLC 65th Anniversary

    Forum TV: Interview with Chris Alexander

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Interview with Victor Malarek

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview with Stan Kutcher

    Forum TV: Ucrainica - Lubomyr Luciuk-Holodomor

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 02, September 19 2026

    Forum TV: Brilliant Academy

    Forum TV: Ihor Dmytruk Exhibition

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 01, September 12 2026

  • Оголошення
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Гомін - газета, телебачення, радіо
Home Акценти

AMERICA’S OBLIGATION TO UKRAINE BEGAN WITH NUKES IN THE EARLY 1990S

10 Січня, 2024
A A
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

By BOHDAN VITVITSKY

30 Грудня, 2023  

The Hill

 

Does the U.S. have an obligation to aid Ukraine? The short answer to this question, one that many have been evading, is yes. The reasons have to do with America’s choices, policies and actions during the early 1990s.

As the Soviet Union was collapsing, the H. W. Bush and Clinton administrations had a kind of bromance with Russian leaders, namely with Mikhail Gorbachev and Boris Yeltsin. There were numerous meetings and telephone calls both on the presidential level and on various ministerial levels. People were on a first-name basis and many American leaders tended to see the world the way Moscow’s leaders did.

When the USSR finally collapsed in December 1991, Soviet nuclear assets were found in the Russian Federation, Ukraine, Kazakhstan and Belarus. Ukraine at that time had the third-largest nuclear arsenal on earth, after the U.S. and Russia. As Eugene Fishel describes at length in his important volume “The Moscow Factor: U.S. Policy toward Sovereign Ukraine and the Kremlin,” America and Yeltsin had begun to pressure Ukraine and the other two republics to agree to surrender their nuclear arsenals to Russia even before the collapse.

The American desire to accommodate Yeltsin after he became Russia’s president was motivated in part by an understandable interest in maintaining a deescalated state of U.S.-Russian relations and by a desire to help Yeltsin domestically. And so when Yeltsin told Bush at Camp David in 1992 that Moscow’s priority was to see Ukraine, Belarus and Kazakhstan become denuclearized, he found a very receptive ear. There was little awareness or concern that the U.S. was essentially acquiescing to Russia gaining an additional advantage over its former colonial possessions.

Washington’s thinking was Russocentric and perhaps naively hopeful. As an internal State Department memorandum in April 1992 stated, “Nothing is of more central importance in this process than consolidation of nuclear weapons in a democratizing Russia.”

The Clinton administration basically continued Bush’s policies towards Russia and Ukraine. There was domestic pressure inside Ukraine for the nation to keep at least some of the nuclear arsenal as a form of deterrence against future Russian invasions. This was no idle fear — over the preceding century, Ukraine had been invaded by troops from Tsarist Russia, Bolshevik Russia, White or monarchist Russia, or the Soviet Union on at least seven occasions.

But President Clinton and Secretary of State Warren Christopher bullied Ukrainian President Leonid Kravchuk to do our bidding, and at an airport meeting in Ukraine they told Kravchuk in threatening terms that if Ukraine did not agree to transfer its nukes to Russia, “it would be a major setback for Ukraine’s relations with both Russia and the U.S.”

As Fishel has noted, “the U.S. government saw all Ukrainian behavior meant to demonstrate, advocate for, and defend Ukraine’s own independent interests as unhelpful, provocative, and even worthy of ridicule and outright bullying.”

The intense, three-year arm-twisting campaign resulted in Ukraine’s agreeing in 1994 to transfer all of its nuclear arsenal to Russia and to sign on to the Non-Proliferation Treaty. In exchange, Ukraine received the so-called Budapest Memorandum, signed by the U.S., the United Kingdom, Russia and Ukraine, in which all of the signatories committed to assure Ukraine of its sovereignty and territorial integrity.

But in 2014, Russia invaded and occupied parts of Ukraine, and since February 2022 Russia has attacked and tried to destroy all of Ukraine.

Was it delusional on our part to think or expect Russia to become a good international citizen? Given Ukraine’s history of having suffered repeated invasions, was it a mistake for us to bully Ukraine into giving up the nuclear arsenal on its territory? Should Ukraine have been made to surrender its nuclear arsenal to, of all places, Russia? Whatever the case, there was only one upper-level official in our government who thought that our preferential orientation towards Moscow was a mistake, and that actor was Dick Cheney, then Bush’s secretary of defense.

It is noteworthy that President Clinton, one of the principal agents inducing Ukraine to give up its nukes, said during an April 2023 interview that he now regrets his role in getting Ukraine to forfeit its nuclear weapons in 1994, and he has suggested that Russia would not have invaded had Ukraine still had its nuclear deterrent. But this and the whole story behind the Budapest Memorandum and Ukraine’s agreement to denuclearize seems altogether to have escaped Congress’s notice or its collective institutional memory.

Over the centuries, we have developed a clear understanding of the obligations that flow from agreements involving a bargained-for exchange. If pursuant to an agreement one party produces that for which the two parties bargained — and here Ukraine did surrender its nukes — then the second party needs to produce that which was bargained for — here a defense of Ukraine’s sovereignty and territorial integrity. Aid to Ukraine is that bargained-for consideration.

Some in Congress today seem to think that aid to Ukraine is a charitable-giving option and act accordingly. Others understand that it is a matter of our geopolitical interests. But none seem to grasp that, based on our having pressured and induced Ukraine to surrender all of its nuclear arms to Russia, it is actually a matter of obligation.

 

Bohdan Vitvitsky, a retired federal prosecutor, served as a resident legal advisor at the American Embassy in Kyiv and then as special advisor to Ukraine’s Prosecutor General.

 

Share198Tweet124
Previous Post

VLADIMIR PUTIN’S UKRAINIAN GENOCIDE: NOBODY CAN CLAIM THEY DID NOT KNOW

Next Post

ІСТОРИЧНИЙ МОМЕНТ

Related Posts

Полиште сподівання на швидкий мир

22 Жовтня, 2026

Олег Медуниця Останні переговори американців із росіянами вкотре підтвердили очевидне: нічого принципово не змінилося. Попри дипломатичну активність, гучні заяви та...

Потреба національної солідарності

17 Жовтня, 2026

Олег Вітвіцький Напередодні чергової важкої зими, в умовах війни, надзвичайно важливим, якщо не вирішальним фактором задля збереження української державності знову...

Це ж було вже

Це ж було вже

16 Жовтня, 2026

Григорій Рій Трамп оголосив про досягнення домовленості з Путіним щодо постачання російського дизелю на американський і світовий ринки. Постає питання:...

Лицемірні «миротворці»

15 Жовтня, 2026

Андрій Гарасим В українській політиці побільшало «мироносців», які подають поступки агресору в обгортці мирної угоди і виступають суголосно з російською...

Next Post
ІСТОРИЧНИЙ МОМЕНТ

ІСТОРИЧНИЙ МОМЕНТ

Реклама

Газета виходить за підтримки Уряду Канади

520px-Government_of_Canada_signature

Інформація

  • Про нас
  • Редакція
  • Розсилка
  • Реклама
  • Спонсори
  • Оголошення
  • Архів

Соцмережі

HominForumTV

© Гомін України, | Усі права застережено.

Політика конфіденційності            Умови використання

Powered by Urban Block Media 

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • Головна
  • Усі новини
    • Акценти
    • Діаспора
    • Економіка та бізнес
    • Жіноцтво
    • Збройні Сили України
    • Історія
    • Канадські події
    • Література і мистецтво
    • Молодь
    • Навколо світу
    • Наука і освіта
    • Новини з України
    • Політика
    • Посмертні згадки
    • Релігія і філософія
    • Спорт
    • Українці в Канаді
  • Світ
  • Україна
  • Канада
  • Новини
  • Політика
  • Форум ТБ
  • Оголошення
  • en EN
  • uk UA
HominForumTV

© Гомін України, | Усі права застережено.