Homin - newspaper, television, radio
Radioprograma Song Of Ukraine
HominForumTV
Пожертва
Розсилка
No Result
View All Result
  • en EN
  • uk UA
  • Home
  • All News
    • News from Ukraine
    • Around the Globe
    • Politics
    • Commentary
    • Diaspora
    • Canadian issues
    • History
    • Ukrainians in Canada
    • Literature and Art
    • Religion and philosophy
    • Science and education
    • Youth
    • Sport
    • In Memoriam
  • Around the Globe
  • Ukraine
  • Canada
  • Politics
  • Forum TV

    Forum TV: Vechornytsi - Za Dvoma Zaitsiamy

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 10, November 14, 2026

    Forum TV: Levada & Orion 40 Years concert

    Forum TV: Vyshyvanka Commemorative Bench Unveiling

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Anna Kisil Commemoration Concret

    Forum TV: Ucrainica - Lubomyr Luciuk - "Holodomor" - Full version

    Forum TV: Interview with Refat Chubarov

    Forum TV: Interview with ViolaSet

    Forum TV: Remembrance Day - 2026

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us #5

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 09, November 07 2026

    Метелики спогадів Ірини Сеник

    Forum TV: 17-ті Вечорниці, організовані Ліґою Українок Канади відділ Торонто. “За двома зайцями”

    Forum TV: Law and Us #3

    Forum TV: Musical Fridays - Ludwig van Beethoven - Sonata N9

    Forum TV: Canadian Bandurist Capella Concert - "Bakhmut Fortress"

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us #4

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 08, October 31, 2026

    Forum TV: UCRAINICA, Alik Homelsky Lecture - full version

    Forum TV: Alik Homelsky Lecture

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview STAN KUTCHER Bill Passed

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview with Eva Rayska

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Anna Kisil Commemoration Concret

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 07, October 24, 2026

    Forum TV: Law and Us #2

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Interview with Taras Podilsky

    Forum TV: Ukrainian Fest - Cultural Segment

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 06, October 17, 2026

    Forum TV: UCWC Toronto Lesia Ukrainka Commemoration

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 05, October 10 2026

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us - «Закон і Ми»

    Forum TV: Interview with Анна Паленчук

    Forum TV: KUMF - Oleg Lipchenko exhibition, «Il Carosello Divino»

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 04, October 03 2026

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Ukrainian Fest - Community Segment

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    UCWLC 65th Anniversary

    Forum TV: Interview with Chris Alexander

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Interview with Victor Malarek

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview with Stan Kutcher

    Forum TV: Ucrainica - Lubomyr Luciuk-Holodomor

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 02, September 19 2026

    Forum TV: Brilliant Academy

  • Classifieds
  • Home
  • All News
    • News from Ukraine
    • Around the Globe
    • Politics
    • Commentary
    • Diaspora
    • Canadian issues
    • History
    • Ukrainians in Canada
    • Literature and Art
    • Religion and philosophy
    • Science and education
    • Youth
    • Sport
    • In Memoriam
  • Around the Globe
  • Ukraine
  • Canada
  • Politics
  • Forum TV

    Forum TV: Vechornytsi - Za Dvoma Zaitsiamy

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 10, November 14, 2026

    Forum TV: Levada & Orion 40 Years concert

    Forum TV: Vyshyvanka Commemorative Bench Unveiling

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Anna Kisil Commemoration Concret

    Forum TV: Ucrainica - Lubomyr Luciuk - "Holodomor" - Full version

    Forum TV: Interview with Refat Chubarov

    Forum TV: Interview with ViolaSet

    Forum TV: Remembrance Day - 2026

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us #5

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 09, November 07 2026

    Метелики спогадів Ірини Сеник

    Forum TV: 17-ті Вечорниці, організовані Ліґою Українок Канади відділ Торонто. “За двома зайцями”

    Forum TV: Law and Us #3

    Forum TV: Musical Fridays - Ludwig van Beethoven - Sonata N9

    Forum TV: Canadian Bandurist Capella Concert - "Bakhmut Fortress"

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us #4

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 08, October 31, 2026

    Forum TV: UCRAINICA, Alik Homelsky Lecture - full version

    Forum TV: Alik Homelsky Lecture

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview STAN KUTCHER Bill Passed

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview with Eva Rayska

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Anna Kisil Commemoration Concret

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 07, October 24, 2026

    Forum TV: Law and Us #2

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Interview with Taras Podilsky

    Forum TV: Ukrainian Fest - Cultural Segment

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 06, October 17, 2026

    Forum TV: UCWC Toronto Lesia Ukrainka Commemoration

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 05, October 10 2026

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us - «Закон і Ми»

    Forum TV: Interview with Анна Паленчук

    Forum TV: KUMF - Oleg Lipchenko exhibition, «Il Carosello Divino»

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 04, October 03 2026

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Ukrainian Fest - Community Segment

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    UCWLC 65th Anniversary

    Forum TV: Interview with Chris Alexander

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Interview with Victor Malarek

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview with Stan Kutcher

    Forum TV: Ucrainica - Lubomyr Luciuk-Holodomor

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 02, September 19 2026

    Forum TV: Brilliant Academy

  • Classifieds
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Homin - newspaper, television, radio
Home Commentary

How Western intelligence agencies helped Vladimir Putin

October 15, 2024
A A
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The bloody consequences of misjudging Ukraine’s will to resist

 

Nick Cohen

September 29, 2024

Writing From London

 

Go back to 24 February 2022, the most fateful day in Europe this century: the day when Vladimir Putin sent his armies into Ukraine. The least discussed aspect of the revival of Russian imperialism was the miserable failure of Western intelligence.

It wasn’t that Western analysts missed the invasion—they didn’t. The Biden administration and its allies did an admirable job. They warned Ukraine and Europe, and pre-empted Russian propaganda efforts to create a false pretext for the invasion. But their success ended there. They vastly overestimated Russia’s military prowess while grossly underestimating Ukraine’s resolve—a misjudgement that persists today, with devastating consequences.

Intelligence sources briefed journalists, who then shared these faulty assumptions with the world. “Ukraine’s paucity of air defences and the weakness of its armed forces means that Russia could drive to Kyiv perhaps as easily as American forces reached Baghdad in the Iraq war of 2003,” declared the Economist in the days before the invasion.

“A Russian military campaign could range from standoff strikes to a largescale invasion of Ukraine’s eastern regions, the encirclement of Kyiv, and the taking of Odessa along the coast,” said the influential War on the Rocks foreign policy site. “The question is not what Russia can do militarily in Ukraine, since the answer is almost anything, but what kind of operation might attain lasting political gains.”

“Almost anything”, eh? Tell that to Russia’s 600,000 casualties.

Not to be outdone the Council on Foreign Relations concluded that “Russia’s military is far superior”.

On and on it went. “Ukrainian forces would begin the conflict nearly surrounded from the very start,” opined the supposedly informed journal Foreign Policy, as it loftily informed its readers that it was a waste of time to send Western weapons to Kyiv –  so assured was Putin of instant victory.

The intelligence failures were as great as before the Iraq War of 2003. And once again governments fell for them. So convinced was the Biden administration of the inevitability of Putin taking Kyiv in days, it offered to fly Zelensky to safety. “I need ammunition, not a ride,” was his reply for the ages.

As a report produced by Eliott A. Cohen and Phillips O’Brien for the Center for Strategic and International Studies this week says, “A consensus coalesced around an extreme vision of what Russia could accomplish militarily and a correspondingly pessimistic view of Ukraine’s ability

to resist. Analysts widely stated that Russia could open with a devastating blow [and] in the first few hours, Kyiv could be surrounded.”

Other predictive failures have resulted in introspection and denunciation. The failure of the intelligence services to realise that Saddam Hussein did not possess weapons of mass destruction destroyed the reputations of George W. Bush and Tony Blair. I have heard economists argue that their profession has never recovered the status lost by their failure to predict the 2008 financial crisis.

Yet the inability of the military and intelligence bureaucracies to understand Russia and Ukraine has not led to a serious debate.  Cohen and O’Brien have filled the gap but they are lone voices in an “intelligence community” that has hidden its failure like a Victorian family hiding its guilty secrets.

There is a certain schadenfreude in recognising that esteemed members of the foreign policy establishment were completely wrong. But mocking the Economist or the CIA does not undo the damage they did.

Because the West believed Russia could simply march into Kyiv, we initially failed to send Ukraine the weapons it needed. Even today, there’s a lingering belief in the invincibility of Russian power and a tendency to dismiss Ukraine’s achievements despite everything its forces have endured.

The hard questions aren’t being asked. If Western intelligence misjudged Russia’s capabilities in 2022, how confident should we be today that the CIA is right to stop Kyiv using long-range weapons against Russia because its analysts have concluded that they might provoke a nuclear war?

Analysing why experts go wrong has become an academic discipline ever since Philip Tetlock produced “Expert Political Judgment: How Good Is It? How Can We Know?” in the early 2000s. Tetlock’s rather alarming conclusion was that people who make prediction their business— the experts who appear on television and advise governments and businesses — were, if you will forgive my bluntness, full of shit.

The accuracy of an expert’s predictions has an inverse relationship to his or her self-confidence, renown, and, beyond a certain point, depth of knowledge, Tetlock concluded. A moderately well-informed layperson could guess what is likely to happen as accurately as specialists.

Normally experts, and all of us, predict what we want to be true. But Western analysts did not want Russia to win. You cannot ascribe their mistakes to motivated reasoning.

Instead, as Cohen and O’Brien explain, the intelligence community was dazzled by data and ignored the messy realities of dysfunctional regimes. They failed to grasp the extent of Russia’s institutional corruption, its leadership’s incompetence, and the delusions that ran up the chain of command.

Conversely, Ukraine was depicted by outlets like Foreign Policy and The New York Times as a divided kleptocracy too weak to resist the Russian bear. “Insufficient account was taken of the

fact that Ukraine’s soldiers were defending their homeland and that its people were fighting an existential war for national survival,” the report concludes.

This was an extraordinary failure. The wars of 9/11, let alone the 20th century’s struggles against colonialism, ought to have taught defence establishments that people do not willingly bend the knee to a foreign occupier.

Unfortunately, intelligence experts were too easily impressed by the supposed “professionalism” of the Russian army. As the report acidly observes, “if it were true that the number of professional soldiers married to sophisticated technology invariably trumped motivation and self-belief, the United States might have done better in Vietnam, Afghanistan and Iraq. The analytic failure in Ukraine makes a strong case for something so often lacking in military analysis and the academic world more generally: intellectual humility.”

No humility is on offer. Cohen and O’Brien have raised urgent and for Ukraine deadly questions, about the West’s fatal determination to overestimate Putin’s power. And yet as far as I can see their report has received no media attention whatsoever from the Economist, Foreign Policy and all those other great and good media organisations that fell for the empty predictions of deluded sources. It seems we are all expected to pretend that the West was right all along.

Nicholas Cohen is a British journalist, author and political commentator. He was a columnist for The Observer, and is one for The Spectator. Following accusations of sexual harassment, he left The Observer in 2022 and began publishing on the Substack platform.

 

 

Share200Tweet125
Previous Post

Russians Do Break: Historical and Cultural Context for a Prospective Ukrainian Victory

Next Post

SOMETHING FOR THE HISTORY BOOKS

Related Posts

Trump Tinkers

October 26, 2026

October 26, 2026 DIANE FRANCIS Donald Trump puts the cart before the horse by dangling riches and scrapping sanctions before...

The Moral Component on the Eve of the Midterms in America

October 25, 2026

Askold Lozynskyj Trump's personal envoy, never confirmed by Congress, real estate mogul Steve Witkoff, recently saluted Russian brutal dictator Vladimir...

What Are They Doing to Your Mind?

October 20, 2026

Russia doesn’t always need you to believe its version of events. Sometimes, flooding the conversation with contradictory claims can serve...

A Call to Canadians: Stand Fast in Ukraine’s Darkest Hour

October 19, 2026

LEAGUE OF UKRAINIAN CANADIANS October 16, 2026 | Toronto, Canada The League of Ukrainian Canadians (LUC) condemns the Trump administration’s...

Next Post

SOMETHING FOR THE HISTORY BOOKS

Реклама

The newspaper is getting published with the support of the Government of Canada

520px-Government_of_Canada_signature

Іnformation

  • About Homin
  • Editorial office
  • Subscription
  • Advertisement
  • Classifieds
  • Archive

Social networks

HominForumTV

© Homin of Ukraine, | All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy          Terms of Use

Powered by Urban Block Media 

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • All News
    • Around the Globe
    • Armed Forces of Ukraine
    • Canadian issues
    • Commentary
    • Diaspora
    • Economics and Business
    • History
    • In Memoriam
    • Literature and Art
    • News from Ukraine
    • Politics
    • Posthumous mentions
    • Religion and philosophy
    • Science and education
    • Sport
    • Ukrainians in Canada
    • Womenfolk
    • Youth
  • Around the Globe
  • Ukraine
  • Canada
  • Politics
  • News
  • en EN
  • uk UA
HominForumTV

© Гомін України, | Усі права застережено.