Homin - newspaper, television, radio
Radioprograma Song Of Ukraine
HominForumTV
Пожертва
Розсилка
No Result
View All Result
  • en EN
  • uk UA
  • Home
  • All News
    • News from Ukraine
    • Around the Globe
    • Politics
    • Commentary
    • Diaspora
    • Canadian issues
    • History
    • Ukrainians in Canada
    • Literature and Art
    • Religion and philosophy
    • Science and education
    • Youth
    • Sport
    • In Memoriam
  • Around the Globe
  • Ukraine
  • Canada
  • Politics
  • Forum TV

    Forum TV: Vechornytsi - Za Dvoma Zaitsiamy

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 10, November 14, 2026

    Forum TV: Levada & Orion 40 Years concert

    Forum TV: Vyshyvanka Commemorative Bench Unveiling

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Anna Kisil Commemoration Concret

    Forum TV: Ucrainica - Lubomyr Luciuk - "Holodomor" - Full version

    Forum TV: Interview with Refat Chubarov

    Forum TV: Interview with ViolaSet

    Forum TV: Remembrance Day - 2026

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us #5

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 09, November 07 2026

    Метелики спогадів Ірини Сеник

    Forum TV: 17-ті Вечорниці, організовані Ліґою Українок Канади відділ Торонто. “За двома зайцями”

    Forum TV: Law and Us #3

    Forum TV: Musical Fridays - Ludwig van Beethoven - Sonata N9

    Forum TV: Canadian Bandurist Capella Concert - "Bakhmut Fortress"

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us #4

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 08, October 31, 2026

    Forum TV: UCRAINICA, Alik Homelsky Lecture - full version

    Forum TV: Alik Homelsky Lecture

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview STAN KUTCHER Bill Passed

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview with Eva Rayska

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Anna Kisil Commemoration Concret

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 07, October 24, 2026

    Forum TV: Law and Us #2

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Interview with Taras Podilsky

    Forum TV: Ukrainian Fest - Cultural Segment

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 06, October 17, 2026

    Forum TV: UCWC Toronto Lesia Ukrainka Commemoration

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 05, October 10 2026

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us - «Закон і Ми»

    Forum TV: Interview with Анна Паленчук

    Forum TV: KUMF - Oleg Lipchenko exhibition, «Il Carosello Divino»

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 04, October 03 2026

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Ukrainian Fest - Community Segment

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    UCWLC 65th Anniversary

    Forum TV: Interview with Chris Alexander

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Interview with Victor Malarek

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview with Stan Kutcher

    Forum TV: Ucrainica - Lubomyr Luciuk-Holodomor

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 02, September 19 2026

    Forum TV: Brilliant Academy

  • Classifieds
  • Home
  • All News
    • News from Ukraine
    • Around the Globe
    • Politics
    • Commentary
    • Diaspora
    • Canadian issues
    • History
    • Ukrainians in Canada
    • Literature and Art
    • Religion and philosophy
    • Science and education
    • Youth
    • Sport
    • In Memoriam
  • Around the Globe
  • Ukraine
  • Canada
  • Politics
  • Forum TV

    Forum TV: Vechornytsi - Za Dvoma Zaitsiamy

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 10, November 14, 2026

    Forum TV: Levada & Orion 40 Years concert

    Forum TV: Vyshyvanka Commemorative Bench Unveiling

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Anna Kisil Commemoration Concret

    Forum TV: Ucrainica - Lubomyr Luciuk - "Holodomor" - Full version

    Forum TV: Interview with Refat Chubarov

    Forum TV: Interview with ViolaSet

    Forum TV: Remembrance Day - 2026

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us #5

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 09, November 07 2026

    Метелики спогадів Ірини Сеник

    Forum TV: 17-ті Вечорниці, організовані Ліґою Українок Канади відділ Торонто. “За двома зайцями”

    Forum TV: Law and Us #3

    Forum TV: Musical Fridays - Ludwig van Beethoven - Sonata N9

    Forum TV: Canadian Bandurist Capella Concert - "Bakhmut Fortress"

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us #4

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 08, October 31, 2026

    Forum TV: UCRAINICA, Alik Homelsky Lecture - full version

    Forum TV: Alik Homelsky Lecture

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview STAN KUTCHER Bill Passed

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview with Eva Rayska

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Anna Kisil Commemoration Concret

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 07, October 24, 2026

    Forum TV: Law and Us #2

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Interview with Taras Podilsky

    Forum TV: Ukrainian Fest - Cultural Segment

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 06, October 17, 2026

    Forum TV: UCWC Toronto Lesia Ukrainka Commemoration

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 05, October 10 2026

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us - «Закон і Ми»

    Forum TV: Interview with Анна Паленчук

    Forum TV: KUMF - Oleg Lipchenko exhibition, «Il Carosello Divino»

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 04, October 03 2026

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Ukrainian Fest - Community Segment

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    UCWLC 65th Anniversary

    Forum TV: Interview with Chris Alexander

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Interview with Victor Malarek

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview with Stan Kutcher

    Forum TV: Ucrainica - Lubomyr Luciuk-Holodomor

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 02, September 19 2026

    Forum TV: Brilliant Academy

  • Classifieds
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Homin - newspaper, television, radio
Home Commentary

Expert: Russian Opposition Wants Empire Without Putin

February 4, 2025
A A
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

By Newsman Nona

December 15, 2024

The Daily Handle

 

Russian historian Botakoz Kassymbekova asserts that Russia’s colonial and authoritarian identity is structurally entrenched, resisting reform or democratization. She highlights how the country’s imperial system disproportionately burdens ethnic minorities and its “national republics,” while fostering privileges for metropolitan Russians, perpetuating inequality and unrest.

Russia’s deep-rooted colonialism and imperial identity are not reformable, argues Botakoz Kassymbekova, a historian specializing in Eastern European studies at the University of Zurich. Speaking about Russia’s persistent dominance over its ethnic minorities, Kassymbekova emphasized that imperialism remains central to the nation’s authoritarian governance system.

“Russian dissidents want to retain the empire, which means they want to maintain the status quo,” she said. “This status quo will never bring democracy, simply because an empire is an authoritarian system.”

Following Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, calls for the decolonization of Russia—a sprawling state that spans 11 time zones and houses over 140 million people—have intensified. Activists argue that Russia operates as one of the last empires in existence, with centralized control exercised from Moscow over its numerous “national republics.” These republics, ostensibly autonomous regions designed to accommodate ethnic minorities, are ruled by Moscow-appointed governors and lack meaningful self-governance.

 

Russia’s National Republics: A Colonial System

Nine out of Russia’s ten poorest regions are national republics. These areas bear the brunt of Russia’s war efforts in Ukraine, suffering disproportionately high mobilization rates and battlefield deaths per capita compared to metropolitan areas like Moscow and St. Petersburg. Calls for decolonization and the rejection of Russification—a policy erasing local identities—are gaining momentum in these marginalized regions.

Kassymbekova, originally from Kazakhstan, draws a sharp contrast between these republics and former Soviet states such as her homeland, which regained independence in the 1990s. Kazakhstan and other nations have fought hard to reclaim their languages and cultures after decades of Russification. By contrast, Russia’s national minorities remain politically and economically dependent on Moscow.

 

The Soviet Legacy: Myth vs. Reality

Romanticized perceptions of the Soviet Union as an anti-imperial, egalitarian state endure in some Western circles. However, Kassymbekova dismisses such views as misguided. “The Marxist theory privileged by some Western scholars often overlooks the human suffering caused by centralized control,” she said. The Soviet model, built on central planning and authoritarian rule, caused widespread oppression, famine, and death, particularly under Joseph Stalin.

The historian sees strong parallels between the Soviet famine in Ukraine (Holodomor) and a similar famine in Kazakhstan, both caused by forced collectivization. These shared traumas, along with efforts to erase cultural elites and suppress independence movements, underscore the colonial nature of Soviet policies.

 

The Revival of Russian Imperialism

Under Vladimir Putin, Russia’s government has revived Stalin-era rhetoric and embraced an imperialist narrative. This includes promoting the idea of the “Russian world,” portraying the country as a sacrificial force bringing good to others. Kassymbekova explained that this narrative, rooted in religious archetypes like martyrdom, frames Russian imperialism as altruistic, while suppressing dissent by glorifying suffering.

“The annexation of Crimea allowed Russians to feel privileged,” she noted, reinforcing a sense of superiority over non-Russians and solidifying support for authoritarian rule. Despite these dynamics, Kassymbekova is skeptical about meaningful change arising from Russia’s political opposition, which she claims is often complicit in maintaining imperial structures.

 

Opposition Without Decolonization

Russian dissidents, often hailed as reformers  in  the  West, resist discussions about dismantling the empire, Kassymbekova said. “Many Russian opposition figures want to preserve the empire and maintain their privileges,” she observed, accusing them of ignoring voices from national republics such as the Bashkirs, Tatars, and Chechens.

Recent proposals for a new Russian constitution, created by Russian intellectuals abroad, even suggested abolishing national republics without consulting their representatives. “This erasure of national identities highlights the deeply ingrained racism and xenophobia within Russian political culture,” she argued.

 

A Turning Point in National Republics

While Russia’s metropolitan elites remain entrenched in imperial privilege, Kassymbekova sees hope in the rising national consciousness of its republics. Many of these regions share historical traumas with Ukraine, fueling their determination to resist Russian domination.

In regions devastated by high war casualties, a critical mass of citizens is rejecting the Kremlin’s authority. Kassymbekova sees these national republics, rather than Moscow-based dissidents, as the most likely catalysts for systemic change in Russia. “We are at a historical moment,” she said. “The myth of the Russian Empire and its greatness has died and won’t be revived anytime soon.”

She concluded that Russia’s colonial identity is fundamentally incompatible with democracy. For meaningful transformation to occur, Russia must confront its imperial history and relinquish its hold over the national republics. Without this reckoning, she warns, the authoritarian regime will persist.

 

Share199Tweet124
Previous Post

OPEN LETTER TO JUSTICE MINISTER VIRANI

Next Post

Holocaust survivor draws parallel between Nazi terror and today’s Russia in Bundestag address

Related Posts

Trump Tinkers

October 26, 2026

October 26, 2026 DIANE FRANCIS Donald Trump puts the cart before the horse by dangling riches and scrapping sanctions before...

The Moral Component on the Eve of the Midterms in America

October 25, 2026

Askold Lozynskyj Trump's personal envoy, never confirmed by Congress, real estate mogul Steve Witkoff, recently saluted Russian brutal dictator Vladimir...

What Are They Doing to Your Mind?

October 20, 2026

Russia doesn’t always need you to believe its version of events. Sometimes, flooding the conversation with contradictory claims can serve...

A Call to Canadians: Stand Fast in Ukraine’s Darkest Hour

October 19, 2026

LEAGUE OF UKRAINIAN CANADIANS October 16, 2026 | Toronto, Canada The League of Ukrainian Canadians (LUC) condemns the Trump administration’s...

Next Post

ONE GUARANTEE STARTS WAR, ANOTHER WANTS TO CHOOSE BY THE THREAD?

Реклама

The newspaper is getting published with the support of the Government of Canada

520px-Government_of_Canada_signature

Іnformation

  • About Homin
  • Editorial office
  • Subscription
  • Advertisement
  • Classifieds
  • Archive

Social networks

HominForumTV

© Homin of Ukraine, | All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy          Terms of Use

Powered by Urban Block Media 

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • All News
    • Around the Globe
    • Armed Forces of Ukraine
    • Canadian issues
    • Commentary
    • Diaspora
    • Economics and Business
    • History
    • In Memoriam
    • Literature and Art
    • News from Ukraine
    • Politics
    • Posthumous mentions
    • Religion and philosophy
    • Science and education
    • Sport
    • Ukrainians in Canada
    • Womenfolk
    • Youth
  • Around the Globe
  • Ukraine
  • Canada
  • Politics
  • News
  • en EN
  • uk UA
HominForumTV

© Гомін України, | Усі права застережено.