Homin - newspaper, television, radio
Radioprograma Song Of Ukraine
HominForumTV
Пожертва
Розсилка
No Result
View All Result
  • en EN
  • uk UA
  • Home
  • All News
    • News from Ukraine
    • Around the Globe
    • Politics
    • Commentary
    • Diaspora
    • Canadian issues
    • History
    • Ukrainians in Canada
    • Literature and Art
    • Religion and philosophy
    • Science and education
    • Youth
    • Sport
    • In Memoriam
  • Around the Globe
  • Ukraine
  • Canada
  • Politics
  • Forum TV

    Forum TV: Vechornytsi - Za Dvoma Zaitsiamy

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 10, November 14, 2026

    Forum TV: Levada & Orion 40 Years concert

    Forum TV: Vyshyvanka Commemorative Bench Unveiling

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Anna Kisil Commemoration Concret

    Forum TV: Ucrainica - Lubomyr Luciuk - "Holodomor" - Full version

    Forum TV: Interview with Refat Chubarov

    Forum TV: Interview with ViolaSet

    Forum TV: Remembrance Day - 2026

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us #5

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 09, November 07 2026

    Метелики спогадів Ірини Сеник

    Forum TV: 17-ті Вечорниці, організовані Ліґою Українок Канади відділ Торонто. “За двома зайцями”

    Forum TV: Law and Us #3

    Forum TV: Musical Fridays - Ludwig van Beethoven - Sonata N9

    Forum TV: Canadian Bandurist Capella Concert - "Bakhmut Fortress"

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us #4

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 08, October 31, 2026

    Forum TV: UCRAINICA, Alik Homelsky Lecture - full version

    Forum TV: Alik Homelsky Lecture

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview STAN KUTCHER Bill Passed

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview with Eva Rayska

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Anna Kisil Commemoration Concret

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 07, October 24, 2026

    Forum TV: Law and Us #2

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Interview with Taras Podilsky

    Forum TV: Ukrainian Fest - Cultural Segment

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 06, October 17, 2026

    Forum TV: UCWC Toronto Lesia Ukrainka Commemoration

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 05, October 10 2026

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us - «Закон і Ми»

    Forum TV: Interview with Анна Паленчук

    Forum TV: KUMF - Oleg Lipchenko exhibition, «Il Carosello Divino»

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 04, October 03 2026

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Ukrainian Fest - Community Segment

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    UCWLC 65th Anniversary

    Forum TV: Interview with Chris Alexander

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Interview with Victor Malarek

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview with Stan Kutcher

    Forum TV: Ucrainica - Lubomyr Luciuk-Holodomor

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 02, September 19 2026

    Forum TV: Brilliant Academy

  • Classifieds
  • Home
  • All News
    • News from Ukraine
    • Around the Globe
    • Politics
    • Commentary
    • Diaspora
    • Canadian issues
    • History
    • Ukrainians in Canada
    • Literature and Art
    • Religion and philosophy
    • Science and education
    • Youth
    • Sport
    • In Memoriam
  • Around the Globe
  • Ukraine
  • Canada
  • Politics
  • Forum TV

    Forum TV: Vechornytsi - Za Dvoma Zaitsiamy

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 10, November 14, 2026

    Forum TV: Levada & Orion 40 Years concert

    Forum TV: Vyshyvanka Commemorative Bench Unveiling

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Anna Kisil Commemoration Concret

    Forum TV: Ucrainica - Lubomyr Luciuk - "Holodomor" - Full version

    Forum TV: Interview with Refat Chubarov

    Forum TV: Interview with ViolaSet

    Forum TV: Remembrance Day - 2026

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us #5

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 09, November 07 2026

    Метелики спогадів Ірини Сеник

    Forum TV: 17-ті Вечорниці, організовані Ліґою Українок Канади відділ Торонто. “За двома зайцями”

    Forum TV: Law and Us #3

    Forum TV: Musical Fridays - Ludwig van Beethoven - Sonata N9

    Forum TV: Canadian Bandurist Capella Concert - "Bakhmut Fortress"

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us #4

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 08, October 31, 2026

    Forum TV: UCRAINICA, Alik Homelsky Lecture - full version

    Forum TV: Alik Homelsky Lecture

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview STAN KUTCHER Bill Passed

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview with Eva Rayska

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Anna Kisil Commemoration Concret

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 07, October 24, 2026

    Forum TV: Law and Us #2

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Interview with Taras Podilsky

    Forum TV: Ukrainian Fest - Cultural Segment

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 06, October 17, 2026

    Forum TV: UCWC Toronto Lesia Ukrainka Commemoration

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 05, October 10 2026

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Law and Us - «Закон і Ми»

    Forum TV: Interview with Анна Паленчук

    Forum TV: KUMF - Oleg Lipchenko exhibition, «Il Carosello Divino»

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 04, October 03 2026

    Forum TV: Forum TV: Ukrainian Fest - Community Segment

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    UCWLC 65th Anniversary

    Forum TV: Interview with Chris Alexander

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Interview with Victor Malarek

    Forum TV: Ukraine Now

    Forum TV: Zoom Interview with Stan Kutcher

    Forum TV: Ucrainica - Lubomyr Luciuk-Holodomor

    Forum TV: Season 15 - Episode 02, September 19 2026

    Forum TV: Brilliant Academy

  • Classifieds
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
Homin - newspaper, television, radio
Home Commentary

BRICS Summit: Kremlin’s ‘Anti-Colonialism’ and Russia’s Colonized Nations

October 29, 2024
A A
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The Federal relations expert Harun (Vadim) Sidorov believes that  the BRICS summit held in Kazan  is directly related to the  decolonization agenda  and is “an illustration of the different attitudes of the Kremlin and its opponents towards it.” According to the Idel.Realii columnist, “The Kremlin, which is already facing official  accusations  of colonialism from the West, is actively trying to shift the blame to the West’s relations with the so-called “global South.”

The Russian Foreign Ministry tried to present the adoption of the resolution “Eradication of colonialism in all its forms and manifestations” by the Fourth Committee of the UN General Assembly on 17 October as its victory. The First Deputy Permanent Representative of Russia to the UN, Dmitry Polyansky,  was especially zealous in creating this impression.

In his  Telegram channel,  he began by saying that the adoption of this resolution was a joint initiative of “closest like-minded people,” including Russia, but after a couple of paragraphs he decided to give all the credit to Moscow, stating that it was initiated by Russia and only supported by its “like-minded people.” Polyansky also stated that “the UN will once again launch a critical discussion about the crimes and consequences of the centuries-old era of colonial oppression, as well as about modern neocolonial practices from which independent states continue to suffer.”

In this regard, it will be necessary to say a few words about the international legal context of this action. Its starting point is the UN General Assembly Declaration on the Granting of Independence to Colonial Countries and Nations, adopted on 14 December 1960. However, since then, within the framework of the UN Special Committee on Decolonization (yes,  there is such a thing), the question of its implementation has been regularly raised. This happened this time, not on the initiative of Russia alone, but of several countries, as can be seen from the text of the draft resolution (more about these countries themselves a little later).

True, if we turn to the basic text of the 1960 Declaration, we can see that it is not about “modern neocolonial practices from which independent states continue to suffer,” as Polyansky and other Russian propagandists tried to present. It is precisely about classical colonialism, which consists of “subordinating nations to foreign yoke and domination,” in denying them the realization of the “right to self-determination,” including under the pretext of their “insufficient political, economic and social preparedness or insufficient preparedness in the field of education,” which is characterized as unacceptable. And in other aspects of the policy of colonialism listed there, to which we will return later.

The topic of colonialism was also raised at the BRICS summit in Kazan. In particular, the BRICS foreign ministers in their joint  statement  indicated that “the desire to gain access to minerals, the deposits of which are located mainly in developing countries, should not repeat the past injustice and inhumane history of colonialism.” In essence, this rhetoric coincides with the previously discussed rhetoric of Polyansky and other Russian propagandists. In such cases, they focus on opposing “neocolonialism,” which does not mean depriving nations without their statehood of the right to self-determination, but imposing economic and political conditions on existing states, unfavourable to them.

Meanwhile, the BRICS summit held in Kazan gave reason to talk about colonialism in its most classic form. In the capital of Tatarstan, the “dear guests” from BRICS  were not greeted by signs in the Tatar language along with Russian, English or Chinese, as one might expect in a republic created by the self-determination of the Tatar people and having the nominal status of a state even according to the Constitution of Russia.

In general, Tatarstan met Moscow’s allies on the “anti-colonialist front” deprived of the fruits of self-determination, even in the compromise form that it achieved at the end of the last century. With the rise to power in Russia of the “anti-colonialist for export” Putin, Tatarstan was consistently deprived of the alphabet it had chosen for its national language, the compulsory teaching of the Tatar language as one of the subjects within the framework of Russian-language education in the republic’s schools, a bilateral agreement with Moscow, national public organizations ( banned ) and activists  (forced to leave the country), control over its raw materials sector (the latter, by the way, perfectly corresponds to the Kremlin’s “anti-colonialist” discourse).

This – effectively colonial – status of Tatarstan was colourfully illustrated by its leader with his behaviour towards guests from BRICS, whose grovelling and second-class status were noted by both  Tatar and other opposition national figures.

However, this can hardly confuse those whom Russian diplomats call “the closest associates” in the fight against “neo-colonialism”. Thus, among the authors of the ritual resolution, the adoption of which Russian diplomats were so delighted by, one can find such countries as the People’s Republic of China, the Islamic Republic of Iran and the Syrian Arab Republic. How the right of nations to self-determination, which is the basis of the Declaration of the General Assembly of 1960, is “recognized” by the first of them, can be told by numerous representatives of the Uyghur people – the indigenous population of the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region. But significant problems not only with self-determination, but also with discrimination, denounced in the UN Declaration of 1960, also exist among the Azerbaijanis or the Baloch of Iran, and the Kurds in Assad’s Syria. However, the latter decided to use the Syrian revolution to solve them and effectively withdrew from the subordination of the official Arab nationalist regime of Damascus.

Therefore, if we compare the approaches to the colonialism of the EU on the one hand and the Kremlin – with its “closest associates” – on the other, we can easily notice that, unlike the former, the latter does not focus at all on the rights of the nations subordinate to their governments. In almost all EU countries with an autochthonous multi-ethnic population, representatives of non-dominant nations enjoy official broad autonomy (Catalans, Basques, Walloons, Flemings) and/or can freely create ethnic and regionalist parties advocating for such, or even for complete national independence. For “anti-colonialists” – such as Russia, China, Iran, and Syria – the first either does not exist, or it is a fiction (like the Uyghurs and Tibetans), and the second is excluded by definition due to the dictatorial nature of their regimes.

In BRICS, although it is a politically heterogeneous structure, the ideological tone today is set by states that do not recognize the subjectivity of the nations subordinate to them. Therefore, the symbolic link to its events of nations subordinate to Russian power, an example of which could be observed in Kazan, is an integral part of the Kremlin’s colonial policy towards them. Therefore, the prospects for their decolonization can only be linked to fundamentally different platforms.

Harun (Vadim) Sidorov, PhD in Law, a doctoral student in ethnology at Charles University (Czech Republic), and an expert on national movements of the nations of Russia in general and the Volga-Ural region in particular.

 

Source: abn.org.ua

 

Share198Tweet124
Previous Post

“Russia will arm the Houthis…”

Next Post

National Internment Commemoration Day on October 28

Related Posts

Trump Tinkers

October 26, 2026

October 26, 2026 DIANE FRANCIS Donald Trump puts the cart before the horse by dangling riches and scrapping sanctions before...

The Moral Component on the Eve of the Midterms in America

October 25, 2026

Askold Lozynskyj Trump's personal envoy, never confirmed by Congress, real estate mogul Steve Witkoff, recently saluted Russian brutal dictator Vladimir...

What Are They Doing to Your Mind?

October 20, 2026

Russia doesn’t always need you to believe its version of events. Sometimes, flooding the conversation with contradictory claims can serve...

A Call to Canadians: Stand Fast in Ukraine’s Darkest Hour

October 19, 2026

LEAGUE OF UKRAINIAN CANADIANS October 16, 2026 | Toronto, Canada The League of Ukrainian Canadians (LUC) condemns the Trump administration’s...

Next Post

National Internment Commemoration Day on October 28

Реклама

The newspaper is getting published with the support of the Government of Canada

520px-Government_of_Canada_signature

Іnformation

  • About Homin
  • Editorial office
  • Subscription
  • Advertisement
  • Classifieds
  • Archive

Social networks

HominForumTV

© Homin of Ukraine, | All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy          Terms of Use

Powered by Urban Block Media 

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • All News
    • Around the Globe
    • Armed Forces of Ukraine
    • Canadian issues
    • Commentary
    • Diaspora
    • Economics and Business
    • History
    • In Memoriam
    • Literature and Art
    • News from Ukraine
    • Politics
    • Posthumous mentions
    • Religion and philosophy
    • Science and education
    • Sport
    • Ukrainians in Canada
    • Womenfolk
    • Youth
  • Around the Globe
  • Ukraine
  • Canada
  • Politics
  • News
  • en EN
  • uk UA
HominForumTV

© Гомін України, | Усі права застережено.